Hey man, 5/9 is still good closing rate. I'm not sure which type of girls you're pulling, but there are some girls who wouldn't have sex on the first night even though they came to your place. The fact that they are heavily making out with you means you've done things right. Other reason can be: you're coming up too strong, you're desperate to close (they can sense it), you're reactive, they have a period, they have other dudes in orbit...etc. In any case, don't overthink it. Just make sure you do proper game/escalation. It's a numbers game!
