How do I go from here?

You only use the Hey trouble opener if her Tinder bio or photos seem to provocative or if she seems like the party type girl to always go to clubs, get drunk, or do freaky shit. Trouble is used as an adjective in the opener and it’s not a opener to use on any girl. You have to use it with a purpose.

First off, you’re double text was a bad one. A better follow up could have been “Fine, hey *churchgoer” or “Are you always this talkative.” With that being said, follow up with “Am I going to be a bad influence then”

I'd go with "No need to play the innocent card here" but I'm not sure. I'm not an expert